
In this article, we take a look at some of the challenges associated with diversity and inclusion training in the workplace, and discuss how it might be improved with antiracism.
The negative consequences of racism and racial discrimination in the workplace, and the failure of organisations to address them, are well known. For example, organisations that appear to tolerate racist behaviour create a lack of psychological safety for their employees, which leads to disengagement, lower productivity and a higher staff turnover (WEF, 2020). This failure to address racism and to fully utilise Black and minority ethnic (BME) talent means that UK organisations are missing out on a potential estimated £24 billion a year (Baroness McGregor-Smith Review, 2017).
For UK organisations, the business case for diversity and inclusion (D&I) in the workplace is clear. Companies with more diverse teams and all-inclusive culture earn 2.5 times higher cash flow per employee, and inclusive teams are productive by over 35% (McKinsey, 2015).
Growing awareness of the benefits of D&I has seen UK organisations experience a sea change in attitudes to diversity. During the period from 2018 to 2021, jobs with ‘diversity’ and ‘inclusion’ in the title more than doubled, increasing by 115 per cent, according to listings on Indeed (Time for change: Diversity, inclusion and belonging in the UK workplace, 2021). And the trend looks set to continue, with jobs in diversity and inclusion rising 123% since May 2024.
However, while UK employers have increased their investment in efforts, particularly over the past few years, to reduce harmful social biases and promote D&I, unfortunately, the evidence tells us that their investments have borne little fruit; racism and racial discrimination remain woven into the fabric of UK workplaces.
In this post, we delve into the effectiveness of diversity, equity and inclusion training in combating workplace racism and discrimination, and consider antiracist training as a way to add value to existing strategies.
Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) Training
DEI training has become a common practice among organisations aiming to foster more diverse and inclusive workplaces. These training programmes are designed to educate employees about the importance of diversity, promote equitable treatment, and encourage inclusive behaviours. Despite their widespread adoption, recent discussions and research have brought to light several significant limitations of DEI training:
Generic Approach: The majority of current attempts to address workplace racism and racial discrimination are cloaked in the broader (and safer) conversation about diversity. Traditional DEI training often takes a generic approach, treating all employees equally. It aims to eradicate discriminatory behaviour across various protected classes (such as race, gender, sexual orientation). While usually well-intentioned, this approach may not effectively address the unique challenges faced by different groups.
Surface-Level Impact: Many DEI programs focus on raising awareness and promoting tolerance. Unfortunately, these surface-level interventions rarely lead to meaningful behavioural change or address systemic issues.
Lack of Accountability: DEI training may lack clear accountability mechanisms. Completion of a training course does not necessarily translate into tangible actions or a shift in workplace culture.
Inadequate Focus on Power Dynamics: DEI training may not sufficiently address power dynamics, privilege, and historical context. Without understanding these factors, training is unlikely to create lasting change.
Top-down evaluation: The importance of continually assessing training is well known, not only to understand what works and how it can be improved, but also to increase buy-in, so that the purpose and benefits of training are understood by the wider organisation. However, evaluation of DEI strategies in large organisations, while being reasonably well established, is top-down and dominated by case studies and interviews with managers and HR teams. These give insight into approaches used and challenges faced, but don’t do a convincing job of showing what is effective (CIPD, 2019).

Antiracist Training: A Different Approach
Antiracist training takes a more targeted and proactive approach. Here’s how it differs:
Centring on Race: Antiracist training explicitly centres on race. It recognises that racism exists and aims to dismantle it. By focusing on race, it exposes direct links to unequal power structures and institutional practices.
Critical Race Theory (CRT): Antiracist training draws from Critical Race Theory (CRT). CRT acknowledges that systemic racism is embedded in society and institutions. It challenges the notion of colourblindness and encourages active efforts to address racial disparities.
Understanding Privilege: Antiracist training helps participants understand privilege, historical context, and how past systems created uneven playing fields. It encourages lifelong learning and self-reflection.
Interrupting Discrimination: Antiracist training equips individuals with tools to interrupt discriminatory behaviour and foster inclusivity. It empowers people to speak up for themselves and others.
Reflexive Antiracism: An Evolving Perspective
The concept of reflexive antiracism was introduced in an article titled “Reflexive antiracism: A novel approach to diversity training” by Emma Kowal, Hayley Franklin, and Yin Paradies. Reflexive antiracism represents a departure from traditional diversity training approaches. It doesn’t merely scratch the surface of cultural awareness or focus solely on individual biases. Instead, it invites us to engage in deeper self-reflection and systemic analysis. So, what sets it apart?
Reflexive antiracism goes further by encouraging continuous self-examination and adaptation. It involves a deep, ongoing reflection on one’s own biases, actions, and the broader societal structures that perpetuate racism. This approach not only focuses on external actions but also on internal attitudes and beliefs, fostering a more profound and lasting commitment to antiracism.
Reflexive antiracism requires individuals and organisations to:
- Engage in Continuous Learning: Regularly update their understanding of racism and its manifestations.
- Reflect on Personal and Organisational Practices: Critically assess how their actions and policies may contribute to systemic racism.
- Adapt and Evolve: Implement changes based on reflections and feedback, ensuring that antiracist efforts are dynamic and responsive to new insights.
Next Steps
While DEI training remains important, complimenting it with antiracist training can lead to more meaningful and lasting change. Antiracist training offers tangible benefits by empowering individuals to recognise and challenge systemic biases, fostering a more inclusive and respectful workplace. For organisations, this translates to improved employee morale, increased innovation, and a stronger reputation.
By actively addressing and dismantling racism, companies can attract and retain diverse talent, enhance team collaboration, and ultimately drive better business outcomes. This proactive approach empowers employees and managers to create a more equitable workplace environment and, in doing so, contribute to an enduring and mutually beneficial change in culture.
Share this article
Tweet
Antiracism training with onEvidence
ABC of Anti-Racism is a course of antiracist training developed by onEvidence in partnership with Global Race Centre for Equality, at the University of Lancashire.
