How to Centre the Voice of the Victim in Domestic Homicide Reviews

How to centre the voice of the victim in Domestic Homicide Reviews

Domestic Homicide Reviews (DHRs) are a vital tool for examining the circumstances leading to domestic homicide and identifying ways to prevent future tragedies. Centring the victim’s voice is paramount in these reviews, ensuring their experiences and perspectives are acknowledged and contribute to learning and prevention efforts.

By gathering information from various sources, including family and friends, Victim Personal Statements compiled from existing records, Independent Domestic Violence Advocates, and community and support networks, DHRs can gain a comprehensive understanding of the victim’s life and the abuse they endured.

Whenever I ponder what good behaviours in DHRs might be, I imagine the deceased victim observing a DHR panel meeting. The might like a seat at the table. What would they say?

Frank Mullane, AAFDA CEO

Drawing on the work of Frank Mullane MBE, Dr James Rowland, Sarah Dangar, Dr Roxanne Khan, and other domestic abuse and violence practitioners and researchers, we take a look at how this multifaceted approach ensures that the review process is both thorough and sensitive to the complex realities of domestic violence. We also introduce our ideas for creative approaches in the DHR process.

The person

Although it may seem obvious, referring to the victim by name throughout the DHR process and using their photo helps to humanise them, ensuring they are remembered as a person rather than an object. This practice fosters empathy and respect, reminding everyone involved that the victim was a real person with a life, family, and dreams. It also helps to keep the focus on the human impact of the crime, which can be a powerful motivator for change and improvement in policies and practices.

Family and friends’ testimonies

Family and friends of victims can offer unparalleled perspectives on the victim’s life, personality, and experiences with the perpetrator. This information is crucial for humanising the victim and understanding the full context of the abuse. Their testimonies can illuminate patterns of abuse that may not have been reported to authorities, shedding light on the escalation of violence and the victim’s attempts to seek help.

These personal accounts are essential for understanding the emotional and psychological toll the abuse took on the victim. Beyond the immediate impacts of abuse, family and friends can also provide valuable information about the victim’s support systems and any obstacles they encountered when trying to access help. This knowledge can be instrumental in shaping recommendations to improve support services and prevent future tragedies. However, it is imperative to approach these testimonies with sensitivity and respect, ensuring the review process is conducted ethically and that the privacy and dignity of the victim and their loved ones are preserved.

Victim Personal Statements

Victim Personal Statements (VPS) are a powerful way to represent the voice of victims in Domestic Homicide Reviews. Although the victim cannot provide a statement themselves, compiling a VPS from existing records can help convey their thoughts and feelings.

Existing records such as diaries, letters, or social media posts can be invaluable sources of information. These personal documents can provide direct insights into the victim’s experiences, emotions, and thoughts. They can help to provide a picture of the victim and give a voice to their lived experiences.

In addition to these personal records, input from professionals who worked with the victim can also be included in the VPS. Social workers, therapists, or domestic violence advocates can offer valuable context and insights into the victim’s experiences, including the types of support they received. This information can be helpful in understanding the broader context of the victim’s life and the challenges they faced.

Independent Domestic Violence Advocates (IDVAs)

Independent Domestic Violence Advocates (IDVAs) play a vital role in representing the voice of victims in DHRs. These professionals are trained to support victims of domestic abuse and often have a deep understanding of their story, including their experiences and needs.

IDVAs can provide valuable insights into the victim’s situation, including the nature and extent of the abuse they endured. They often have detailed knowledge of the victim’s interactions with support services and can highlight any barriers the victim faced in accessing help. This information is essential for understanding the full context of the victim’s experiences and identifying areas for improvement in service provision.

Moreover, IDVAs can articulate the victim’s needs and concerns, ensuring that their voice is heard in the review process. They can provide a professional perspective on the victim’s experiences, which can be particularly valuable in cases where the victim’s family and friends may not have been fully aware of the extent of the abuse.

It is important to approach the involvement of IDVAs with sensitivity and respect, ensuring that their contributions are valued. By incorporating the insights and perspectives of IDVAs, DHRs can ensure that the victim’s voice is represented and that their experiences contribute to learning and prevention efforts.

Community and support networks

Community and support networks can provide valuable insights into the victim’s life, their interactions within the community, and the support they received or lacked.

Community groups and local organisations often have a deep understanding of the victim’s circumstances and the broader social context in which the abuse occurred. They can provide testimonies about the victim’s involvement in community activities, their relationships with neighbours, and any signs of distress or abuse that were observed. This information can help to build a comprehensive picture of the victim’s experiences and the impact of the abuse on their life.

Support networks, including domestic violence charities and advocacy groups, can offer detailed accounts of the victim’s interactions with support services. These organisations often have records of the victim’s attempts to seek help, the barriers they faced, and the effectiveness of the support provided. This information is crucial for identifying gaps in service provision and making recommendations for improvement.

Importantly, involving community and support networks in DHRs can help to amplify the victim’s voice and ensure that their experiences are not overlooked. These networks can advocate on behalf of the victim, ensuring that their needs and concerns are represented in the review process. This can lead to more informed and effective recommendations for preventing future domestic homicides.

Learning from past reviews

To improve responses and prevent future tragedies, DHRs must consider the learning from past reviews. Analysing previous reviews can provide valuable insights into patterns, risk factors, and areas where interventions can be more effective.

Past reviews often highlight common themes and lessons learned. These can include the importance of early intervention, the need for better communication and information sharing between agencies, and the necessity of comprehensive risk assessments. By identifying these recurring themes, agencies can develop targeted strategies to address them.

Reviewing past DHRs can also reveal gaps in service provision and areas where improvements are needed. For example, some reviews may identify a lack of support for victims with specific vulnerabilities, such as mental health issues or substance abuse problems. Addressing these gaps can lead to more effective support services and better outcomes for victims.

Additionally, past reviews can provide examples of good practice that can be replicated in future cases. This can include successful multi-agency collaborations, effective use of risk assessment tools, and innovative approaches to supporting victims. By learning from these examples, agencies can adopt best practices and improve their responses to domestic abuse.

Finally, analysing past DHRs can help to identify trends and patterns in domestic homicides. This can include understanding the characteristics of victims and perpetrators, the types of abuse experienced, and the circumstances leading up to the homicide.

Training for practitioners

Training for practitioners involved in Domestic Homicide Reviews helps to ensure that reviews are conducted effectively and sensitively. Proper training equips practitioners with the necessary skills and knowledge to handle these complex and emotionally charged cases.

Training programmes often cover the fundamentals of the DHR process, including the legal framework, the roles and responsibilities of different agencies, and the importance of a multi-agency approach. This foundational knowledge is crucial for practitioners to understand the scope and objectives of DHRs.

Specialised training courses, such as those delivered by AAFDA, for DHR chairs and panel members is available. This training focuses on the specific skills required to lead a review, such as conducting interviews, analysing evidence, and writing comprehensive reports. It also highlights the importance of engaging with the victim’s family and friends in a sensitive and respectful manner.

Ongoing professional development is vital. Practitioners are encouraged to participate in continuous learning opportunities, such as workshops, seminars, and online courses. These opportunities help practitioners stay updated on best practices, new research, and emerging trends in domestic violence and homicide prevention.

Finally, training programmes often include modules on ethical considerations and the emotional impact of DHRs. Practitioners learn how to handle sensitive information, maintain confidentiality, and support the emotional well-being of all participants in the review process.

Ethical considerations

Ethical considerations are fundamental to Domestic Homicide Reviews, ensuring the process respects the dignity and privacy of the victim and their loved ones. This commitment to ethical practice is not just a procedural requirement but a moral imperative that underpins the entire review process.

Protecting sensitive information and building trust

Maintaining confidentiality is crucial throughout the DHR process. Practitioners have a responsibility to protect sensitive information about the victim and their family. This includes anonymising data and carefully considering what information is shared in public reports. Obtaining informed consent from the victim’s family and friends is also essential. They should be fully informed about the purpose of the review, how their information will be used, and their right to withdraw from the process at any time. This transparent approach helps build trust and ensures that participation is voluntary and respectful.

Recognising the emotional impact and providing support

It is important to recognise the emotional impact of participating in a DHR. Practitioners should provide support to family members, friends, and professionals who might be affected by revisiting traumatic events. Offering counselling services and ensuring the review process is conducted with sensitivity and care can help mitigate the emotional toll.

Transparency, accountability, and continuous improvement

Transparency and accountability are essential for maintaining public trust in the DHR process. The review process should be open and transparent, with clear communication about the findings and recommendations. This helps ensure the review is seen as a legitimate and constructive process, committed to learning and improvement. Ethical considerations also extend to reflecting on the broader implications of the review. This includes considering how the findings will be used to improve services and prevent future domestic homicides. It also involves a commitment to continually improving the DHR process based on feedback and lessons learned.

By adhering to these ethical principles, DHRs can create a space where the victim’s voice is respected, and the review process contributes to meaningful change within systems and services.

Get creative: an idea for discussion

Creative approaches, particularly arts-based research methods, have been effectively used to overcome barriers in various fields. These methods leverage the power of artistic expression to explore complex and sensitive topics, engage diverse participants, and present findings in impactful ways. By providing the safety of metaphor, visual arts and storytelling, for example, allows people to express reactions and explore feelings that might be uncomfortable or difficult to communicate in more literal ways.

While untested in the process of domestic homicide reviews, creative approaches have the potential to be particularly valuable. Arts-based methods could provide a multi-dimensional view of the victim’s story and the circumstances surrounding their death.

Here are just a few suggestions we hope might get this conversation started:

  • Memory walls: These walls could be created with contributions from the victim’s family, friends, colleagues and community members, containing written memories, stories, poems, messages, photographs of personal items and mementos that tell the story of the victim’s life and personality, and describe the impact of their death. These memory walls can be presented during the review process and included in the final report through detailed descriptions and photographs. This approach humanises the victim and provides a tangible connection to their life, fostering empathy and understanding among those involved in the review, and making their story more impactful and memorable.
  • Photographic walkthroughs: A photo essay or timeline could be created that documents significant places and moments in the victim’s life. This might include their home, workplace, favorite spots, and community spaces. Each photo could be accompanied by captions or short narratives that provide context and highlight the victim’s experiences.
  • Artistic tributes: Artists and graphic designers could be commissioned to create works that reflect the victim’s life and experiences, based around the contents of the memory wall, photographic walkthrough and/or other art-based exercises. These can be included in the report and displayed in public spaces to raise awareness and foster community engagement.

By incorporating creative approaches, DHRs might move beyond standard procedural reviews to create more meaningful and lasting impacts. These methods can help amplify the voice of the victim and raise awareness, as well as ensuring a broader range of voices and perspectives are included in the process.

Conclusion

Representing the victim’s voice in Domestic Homicide Reviews is not just a procedural necessity; it is a moral imperative. By diligently and ethically gathering information from a diverse range of sources – family, friends, personal records, advocates, and community networks – DHRs can offer a multifaceted understanding of the victim’s story. This comprehensive approach ensures that the review process is both thorough and sensitive, honouring the victim’s memory and experiences.

However, the ultimate purpose of DHRs extends beyond understanding; it lies in preventing future tragedies. Analysing past reviews, identifying recurring themes, and addressing gaps in service provision are crucial steps towards creating a more effective and responsive system. Investing in comprehensive training for practitioners, including specialised courses for DHR chairs and panel members, ensures that reviews are conducted with the necessary expertise and sensitivity.

By adhering to ethical principles – confidentiality, informed consent, emotional support, transparency, and accountability – DHRs can cultivate public trust and contribute to meaningful change.

Only through continuous learning, improvement, innovation, and a steadfast commitment to understanding the victim’s story, can DHRs truly fulfil their purpose of preventing future domestic homicides and ensuring that no voice is ever silenced again.


Domestic-Homicide-Review-Chair-and-Author-services

Domestic Homicide Reviews with onEvidence

onEvidence works with community safety partnerships (CSPs) to provide independent Domestic Homicide Review Chair and Overview Report Writer services, across England and Wales.


Sources

Rowlands, James (2020). The ethics of victim voice in Domestic Homicide Reviews. University of Sussex. Journal contribution. https://hdl.handle.net/10779/uos.23478074.v1.

Home Office. (2021, September). Key findings from analysis of domestic homicide reviews: October 2019 to September 2020. Retrieved 21 Nov. 2024, from https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/key-findings-from-analysis-of-domestic-homicide-reviews/key-findings-from-analysis-of-domestic-homicide-reviews.

Dangar, Sarah. (2024, May 22). Domestic Homicide Reviews: The role of family, friends and community – ‘A hierarchy of testimony’? AAFDA. Retrieved 21 Nov. 2024, from https://aafda.org.uk/storage/News%20items/DHRs%20-%20the%20role%20of%20family,%20friends%20and%20community_Briefing%20Paper.pdf.

Home Office. (2024, October 31). Key findings from analysis of domestic homicide reviews: September 2021 to October 2022. Retrieved 21 Nov. 2024, from https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/key-findings-from-analysis-of-domestic-homicide-reviews/key-findings-from-analysis-of-domestic-homicide-reviews-september-2021-to-october-2022-accessible.

Home Office. (2013, March 28). Conducting a domestic homicide review: online learning. Retrieved 22 Nov. 2024, from https://www.gov.uk/guidance/conducting-a-domestic-homicide-review-online-learning.

Jones, C., Bracewell, K., Clegg, A., Stanley, N., & Chantler, K. (2024). Domestic Homicide Review Committees’ Recommendations and Impacts: A Systematic Review. Homicide Studies, 28(1), 78-98. https://doi.org/10.1177/10887679221081788.