Child Safeguarding Practice Reviews: Including the Child’s Voice for Better Outcomes

Are we listening to victims in Child Safeguarding Practice Reviews

Child Safeguarding Practice Reviews (CSPRs) serve as a vital mechanism for in-depth learning and the enhancement of inter-agency collaboration in safeguarding children. Triggered when a child dies or suffers significant harm, and where abuse or neglect is suspected or confirmed, these reviews aim to identify lessons that can prevent future tragedies. Central to this process is the imperative to understand the lived experience of the child, particularly when they have been a victim of harm. This article will explore the critical importance of embedding the child’s perspective within CSPRs, outlining effective, victim-centred, and trauma-informed methodologies. Furthermore, it will consider the inherent complexities and challenges in facilitating meaningful participation for children within these sensitive processes.

The indispensable role of the child’s voice

Integrating the perspectives of children within CSPRs transcends mere good practice; it forms a fundamental pillar for achieving meaningful and effective safeguarding improvements. The reasons for this are manifold:

  • Empowerment and validation: Providing a platform for children to express their experiences is an act of empowerment and profound validation. For children who have suffered abuse or neglect, this can be a pivotal element in their journey towards healing, fostering a sense of being heard, valued, and respected.
  • Enhanced understanding: Children possess unique insights into their own lives, family dynamics, and the environments they inhabit. Their perspectives can yield a richer, more nuanced comprehension of the circumstances that contributed to the harm, potentially illuminating crucial factors that might be overlooked through an adult lens alone.
  • More effective outcomes: Recommendations derived from reviews that genuinely incorporate the child’s voice are far more likely to be relevant and impactful. This is because they are rooted in a holistic understanding of the child’s needs and lived realities, moving beyond perspectives that are solely adult-centric.
  • Legal and ethical imperative: The inclusion of the child’s voice in matters that affect them is not only an ethical imperative but is also firmly embedded within UK law and international conventions. For instance, the Children Act 1989 and subsequent legislation place a duty on relevant authorities to have regard to the child’s wishes and feelings. Furthermore, the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), to which the UK is a signatory, explicitly emphasises the child’s right to be heard and have their views given due weight in all judicial and administrative proceedings affecting the child.

Effective and innovative methodologies for incorporating the child’s voice

A range of sensitive, child-centred, and increasingly innovative approaches are essential for effectively integrating children’s perspectives into CSPRs:

  • Direct participation: Where deemed appropriate and safe, direct engagement should be prioritised. Alongside facilitated interviews and discussions, consider the ethical and carefully managed use of age-appropriate digital tools like interactive apps or secure online platforms to offer alternative avenues for expression. Rigorous safeguarding protocols and age-appropriateness are paramount for any digital methods.
  • Independent and child-led advocacy: Independent advocates play a vital role in representing the child’s voice. Furthermore, explore opportunities to empower children within this process, where appropriate, potentially through child-led elements or peer advocacy models under careful guidance and supervision.
  • Creative and multi-sensory communication techniques: Employing drawing, storytelling, and therapeutic play remains crucial. Expanding this to include multi-sensory approaches like music, drama, puppetry, or even carefully considered virtual reality environments can cater to diverse communication styles and provide richer insights, particularly for children with sensory needs or those who have experienced trauma. Specialist training in these methods is essential.
  • Interactive feedback and engagement: Providing age-appropriate feedback is key. Consider implementing more interactive and potentially continuous feedback mechanisms, such as visual timelines, and, where suitable for older children, involving them in the development of recommendations to enhance their sense of agency.
  • Deeply embedded trauma-informed practice: Ensure that trauma-informed principles underpin all aspects of the CSPR process. This includes the environment, language, pacing, and a thorough understanding of potential triggers. Consider integrating therapeutic specialists to support both the child and the review team in maintaining a consistently trauma-sensitive approach.
  • Ethical utilisation of anonymised data: With stringent ethical oversight and consent, explore the potential for analysing anonymised and aggregated data from children’s contributions across multiple reviews to identify systemic trends and inform broader preventative recommendations, always prioritising privacy and confidentiality.
  • Training and support for a dynamic approach: Professionals involved in CSPRs require ongoing training and support that encompasses both established best practices and these emerging, innovative methods. This includes not only the “why” and “how” of child participation but also the ethical considerations and practical implementation of new techniques.

Centring the voice of a child who has passed

When a CSPR is conducted following the tragic death of a child due to suspected or confirmed abuse or neglect, directly hearing the child’s voice is no longer possible. However, centring the child’s lived experience and understanding their perspective remains crucial for deriving meaningful lessons and informing improved safeguarding practices. In these circumstances, the review process must actively seek to reconstruct the child’s voice through various means.

Gathering detailed accounts from individuals who had significant contact with the child can provide valuable insights into their daily life, experiences, relationships, and any expressions of their wishes, feelings, or concerns. This includes:

  • Advocates: If the child had an advocate, their perspectives on the child’s views and experiences are essential.
  • Teachers and school staff: Educators often have regular and sustained contact with children and can offer observations about their behaviour, interactions, friendships, academic performance, and any disclosures or changes in demeanour. They may have also been privy to concerns shared by the child.
  • Friends and peers: Age-appropriate engagement with the child’s friends and peers can provide insights into their social interactions, emotional well-being, and any shared experiences or confidences.
  • Extended family members: While caution is needed to understand potential influences, other family members may hold valuable information about the child’s life and experiences.
  • Healthcare professionals: Doctors, nurses, and other healthcare providers may have records of the child’s health, well-being, and any concerns raised during medical interactions.
  • Review of existing records: A comprehensive review of existing records can provide valuable insights into a child’s lived experience, even when their voice was not directly documented. Social care records, including case notes, assessments, and reports, may contain observations of the child’s behaviour, direct quotes, and records of interactions, offering a glimpse into their thoughts and circumstances. Similarly, police records can provide crucial context through any interactions with the child or reports made by or about them, helping to build a fuller understanding of their experiences and the safeguarding concerns they faced.
  • Analysis of non-verbal communication and behaviour: A child’s voice is not limited to words—it can also be expressed through non-verbal cues, behaviour patterns, and emotional responses. Professionals must carefully examine documented observations of these expressions, particularly for younger or less verbal children. Changes in demeanour, withdrawal, anxiety, or other behavioural shifts can provide essential insights into their lived experiences, helping to uncover safeguarding concerns that may otherwise remain unnoticed.

Equally important is understanding the barriers that may have prevented a child’s voice from being heard or acted upon during their lifetime. Power imbalances within the family, cultural barriers, a lack of trusted relationships with professionals, and a tendency to prioritise adult perspectives over the child’s all play a role in suppressing their voice. By analysing these dynamics and seeking every possible avenue to reconstruct their experiences, CSPRs can ensure that the voices of children who have passed continue to inform learning, drive change, and contribute to a stronger safeguarding system for all.

Navigating complexities and key considerations

While the imperative to include the child’s voice is clear, its effective implementation within CSPRs necessitates careful consideration of several inherent challenges:

  • Prioritising safety and ethical participation: A primary concern is the delicate balance between facilitating the child’s participation and safeguarding them from any potential further harm or distress. This requires meticulous planning, thorough risk assessments, and the involvement of experienced practitioners skilled in child protection and trauma-informed practice. Decisions regarding the nature and extent of a child’s involvement must always prioritise their well-being.
  • Ensuring authentic representation: A significant challenge lies in accurately capturing and representing the child’s genuine perspective, free from adult interpretation or bias. Practitioners must be vigilant in avoiding the temptation to filter the child’s views through an adult lens or impose their own understanding. The focus should remain steadfast on presenting the child’s experiences and opinions as faithfully as possible, using their own language and modes of communication.
  • Addressing power dynamics: The inherent power imbalance between children and adults, particularly within a formal review process, can be intimidating for the child. Creating an environment where the child feels safe, valued, and empowered to express themselves openly is paramount. Strategies to mitigate these imbalances include the use of child-friendly language, conducting meetings in comfortable and familiar settings, building a trusting and respectful relationship with the child, and ensuring they understand the purpose of the review and their role within it.
  • Cultivating cultural sensitivity and competence: Practitioners must possess a high degree of cultural sensitivity and competence to understand and respect the diverse ways in which children from different cultural backgrounds may communicate their experiences. This includes awareness of the child’s family and community context, understanding potential cultural barriers to participation, and adapting communication styles and methods to be culturally appropriate and inclusive. Access to interpreters or cultural advisors may be necessary in some cases.

Illustrating the inclusion of the child’s voice in UK Child Safeguarding Practice Reviews

Several key organisations and reports in the UK underscore the critical importance of incorporating the child’s voice within CSPRs, while also acknowledging the persistent challenges in achieving this effectively.

  1. NSPCC learning: The imperative of hearing children’s lived experiences: NSPCC Learning resources consistently highlight that a fundamental aspect of effective safeguarding practice is actively listening to and understanding the lived experiences of children. They emphasise that gaining insight into a child’s perspective on their life and circumstances is crucial for a comprehensive understanding of safeguarding issues. However, the NSPCC also points to significant hurdles faced by professionals in truly hearing and acting upon what children communicate. These challenges include insufficient direct contact with children, a lack of robust challenge to barriers preventing direct engagement, and difficulties in accurately interpreting and reflecting the child’s voice within the review process. Read more.
  2. NSPCC Practice Points: Facilitating the child’s communication: Complementary guidance from the NSPCC offers practical advice for social workers and other professionals on how to better facilitate the voice of the child. Key practice points include the necessity of paying close attention to all forms of communication a child may use (verbal, non-verbal, behavioural), developing a deeper understanding of the meaning behind a child’s behaviour, and adopting a non-judgemental stance when listening to and observing children to encourage openness and trust. Read more.
  3. Ofsted report (2010): A recurrent theme in serious case reviews: A significant Ofsted report analysing 67 serious case reviews from 2010 identified listening to the voice of the child as a recurrent and critical theme. The report highlighted the practice implications of relying on adult accounts of a child’s experiences, the importance of being vigilant to situations where parents or carers may obstruct access to the child, and the fundamental need to maintain a child-centred focus throughout the review, rather than prioritising the needs of adults. This analysis highlights the enduring importance of directly engaging with the child’s perspective in safeguarding inquiries. Read more.

The profound impact on children

Integrating the child’s voice within Child Safeguarding Practice Reviews (CSPRs) transcends mere procedural compliance; it represents a fundamental commitment to a victim-centred and trauma-informed approach to safeguarding. Actively listening to children, particularly those who have endured abuse or neglect, serves as a powerful act of validation, empowering them to become active participants in understanding and addressing what has happened. This empowerment can have a profound and positive impact on their healing and recovery journey, fostering a sense of being seen, truly heard, and treated with respect.

Furthermore, the unique insights children offer can significantly enrich our comprehension of the complex circumstances that contributed to the harm they experienced. Children often possess distinct perspectives on their family dynamics, the behaviours of adults in their lives, and the subtle indicators of abuse or neglect that may not be immediately obvious to professionals. By meaningfully incorporating these firsthand accounts, CSPRs can formulate more precise and comprehensive recommendations that effectively target the underlying causes of harm, thereby strengthening preventative measures for the future.

Addressing legitimate concerns and ensuring robustness

It is important to acknowledge that legitimate questions may arise regarding the reliability of children’s accounts or concerns about potential manipulation influencing their participation in CSPRs. These are valid considerations that necessitate careful and thorough attention to ensure the integrity of the process. To guarantee that the child’s voice is authentically heard and their participation is meaningful and robust, comprehensive safeguards must be integral to the methodology.

A foundational step involves the consistent use of age-appropriate language and a range of child-centred methods when gathering information. Practitioners require specialised training to communicate effectively with children across all developmental stages and to navigate any potential communication barriers with sensitivity and skill. Creating a secure and supportive environment where children feel empowered to express themselves freely is paramount. This necessitates building trust and rapport, employing language that is accessible and reassuring, and selecting a setting that is perceived as welcoming and non-threatening.

To further enhance the accuracy and reliability of children’s accounts, a rigorous approach to corroboration is essential. This includes systematically cross-referencing information obtained from the child with insights from other professionals involved in their lives, such as educators, healthcare providers, or therapists, as well as a thorough review of relevant documentation. The active involvement of highly trained professionals with expertise in child development and child-centred practice is indispensable throughout the entire process. These professionals possess the skills to sensitively assess a child’s credibility, identify any potential biases or undue influences, and ensure that the child’s best interests remain at the forefront of the review.

Specific recommendations for enhancing Child Safeguarding Practice Reviews

To further strengthen the effectiveness and child-centred nature of CSPRs, the following specific recommendations should be prioritised:

  • Strategic investment in specialised training: Implementing comprehensive and mandatory training modules for all practitioners involved in CSPRs is paramount to equip them with the nuanced skills required to engage meaningfully and ethically with children. This training should encompass a thorough understanding of child development and communication, the importance of recognising and responding to cultural sensitivities, strategies for effectively addressing power imbalances, and the responsible and appropriate use of technology to facilitate child participation. For example, training on secure video conferencing platforms should be integrated to enable practitioners to conduct remote interviews in a manner that prioritises the child’s safety and accessibility.
  • Establishment of clear and accessible principles and local guidance: Developing clear and accessible overarching principles, informed by national best practice, for gathering and incorporating children’s perspectives into CSPRs is essential for fostering a consistent child-centred approach. These principles should then underpin the development of comprehensive and readily accessible local guidance and protocols that can be adapted to reflect the specific needs and contexts of individual Local Safeguarding Children Partnerships (LSCPs/equivalent in devolved nations). This localised guidance could include standardised protocols for employing creative methodologies, such as drawing and narrative techniques, to elicit information from children, particularly those who may face challenges in verbal expression due to trauma or developmental factors. These protocols must provide clear guidance on age-appropriate techniques, the sensitive interpretation of children’s expressions, and the accurate and ethical documentation of these interactions for the review process, while remaining flexible enough to respond to local needs and resources.
  • Development of robust and child-centred safety protocols: The vital importance of the child’s safety and well-being must be reflected in robust protocols throughout the entirety of the review process. Implementing a comprehensive risk assessment framework and practical tools, such as checklists for practitioners to employ when planning and conducting interviews or interactions with children, is crucial. This framework should explicitly address the child’s emotional well-being, potential triggers, and the provision of necessary breaks and support during engagement. Furthermore, practitioners must receive thorough training to recognise signs of distress or discomfort in children and to respond promptly and appropriately in accordance with safeguarding procedures.
  • Strategic leveraging of technology for enhanced accessibility: A considered exploration and ethical implementation of technology-based solutions can significantly enhance child participation in CSPRs. The development of secure online platforms that enable children to share their experiences through various media, such as text, audio, or video recordings, at their own pace, can empower them to contribute in a safe and comfortable digital environment. These platforms must feature age-appropriate interfaces and functionalities, including options for confidential or anonymous communication and communication with the support of a trusted advocate. The integration of interactive tools, such as digital drawing or music creation software, can also facilitate creative expression. Furthermore, the potential of virtual reality (VR) technology to create safe and immersive environments where children can revisit and share their experiences should be explored ethically and with appropriate safeguards. This technology may be particularly beneficial for children who find verbal articulation challenging or who respond positively to visual and sensory aids.
  • Commitment to continuous research and evaluation: Ongoing, rigorous research and evaluation are vital to critically assess the effectiveness of diverse approaches to including children’s voices in CSPRs. Research efforts should focus on identifying evidence-based best practices, comprehensively understanding the impact of various methods on children’s well-being, and developing data-driven recommendations for continuous improvement. Collaborative partnerships with research organisations can facilitate longitudinal studies to track the long-term effects of child participation in CSPRs. These studies can examine critical outcomes such as children’s emotional well-being, their levels of trust in adults and support systems, and their overall resilience, ultimately informing the development of more effective and profoundly child-centred safeguarding strategies.

By diligently incorporating these recommendations and thoughtfully integrating technological advancements, CSPRs can more effectively capture the invaluable perspectives of children, leading to reviews that are more comprehensive, contextually relevant, and ultimately more effective in contributing to a safer and more supportive environment for all children.

A renewed focus on children’s voices

Including the child’s voice in Child Safeguarding Practice Reviews is a fundamental ethical and practical imperative for building a truly effective safeguarding system. Actively listening to children validates their lived experiences, fostering empowerment and demonstrating profound respect. This is particularly vital for children who have suffered abuse or neglect, as it can be a crucial element in their journey towards healing and recovery, helping them to regain a sense of agency and value.

Providing meaningful feedback to children about the impact of their contributions within the review process further reinforces their sense of being heard and respected. However, genuine inclusion demands more than simple participation. It necessitates unwavering attention to their safety, ensuring their voices are authentically represented without adult bias or interpretation. This requires a conscious and continuous effort to address inherent power imbalances and cultivate culturally sensitive approaches that enable all children to express themselves freely and in ways that feel comfortable and safe.

Innovative technologies hold considerable promise for enhancing children’s engagement in CSPRs, offering accessible and less intimidating avenues for sharing their experiences. Online platforms, creative digital tools, and immersive environments can provide alternative means of communication, particularly for children who struggle with verbal articulation.

Ultimately, by embedding the principles and practices outlined within this article, informed significantly by the guidance of organisations like NSPCC Learning, we can foster a child safeguarding system that is not only more responsive and effective in protecting children but also actively empowers them as crucial informants and participants in ensuring their own safety and well-being. This renewed and sustained focus on the child’s voice will lead to more insightful reviews, better informed recommendations, and, most importantly, a stronger commitment to creating safer futures for all children.


Child-Safeguarding-Practice-Reviews-Chair-services

Child Safeguarding Practice Reviews with onEvidence

Providing Independent Lead Reviewer and Report Author services, onEvidence works with Safeguarding Partnerships to conduct local CSPRs. 


Sources

NSPCC Learning.  (2024, May). The voice of the child: learning from case reviews. Retrieved 18 Nov. 2024, from https://learning.nspcc.org.uk/research-resources/learning-from-case-reviews/voice-child

NSPCC Learning. (2024, October). How can we hear and facilitate the voice of the child? Retrieved 18 Nov. 2024, from https://learning.nspcc.org.uk/research-resources/practice-points-series/voice-child

Ofsted. (2011, April). The voice of the child: learning lessons from serious case reviews. Retrieved 18 Nov. 2024, from  https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/526981/The_voice_of_the_child.pdf